The Best Ice Cream Shops in Peterborough & The Kawarthas

Here’s the scoop—literally! If you’re in Peterborough & the Kawarthas and craving something sweet, creamy, and oh-so-satisfying, you’re in luck. This region is home to some of the best ice cream spots, from classic parlors to hidden gems serving up locally made treats. Whether you're into classic vanilla, adventurous flavors, or that perfect Instagram-worthy cone, I’ve got you covered. Let’s dive in!

1. Central Smith Creamery – The OG of Ice Cream Excellence

📍 739 Lindsay Rd, Selwyn

If you know, you know. Central Smith is a local legend, and for good reason—they've been churning out some of the best ice cream in Ontario for over 125 years! Their flavors? Unreal. Think Kawartha Dairy quality but with a unique, homemade touch. Whether you’re grabbing a scoop at their on-site ice cream counter or finding their pints in local grocery stores, you can’t go wrong. Pro tip: Try Moose Tracks or Salty Caramel Crunch—thank me later.

2. Kawartha Dairy – A Canadian Icon

📍 815 High St. , Peterborough

If you haven't had Kawartha Dairy ice cream, are you even Canadian? This family-owned business has been serving up rich, creamy goodness since 1937. Their Peterborough location is always buzzing, and for a good reason. From their legendary Bordeaux Cherry to their fan-favorite Bear Claw, every scoop is a taste of nostalgia. And yes, their portions are massive, so come hungry!

3. Silver Bean Café – Ice Cream with the Best Waterfront View

📍 130 King St, Peterborough

Ice cream and coffee with a stunning riverside view? Yes, please! Silver Bean Café is a beloved summer hotspot in Peterborough, serving up Kawartha Dairy ice cream along with incredible coffee, baked goods, and light eats. Grab a cone and enjoy it right on the Otonabee River—it’s the perfect way to soak up the sunshine. Their Honey Lavender ice cream is a must-try!

4. Great Outdoors Landing – Ice Cream & More in Bridgenorth

📍 827 Ward St, Bridgenorth

This new addition to Bridgenorth is quickly becoming a favorite! Not only does Great Outdoors Landing offer delicious Kawartha Dairy ice cream, but they also serve up amazing milkshakes, burgers, and snacks. Whether you're stopping by after a day on the lake or just craving something sweet, this spot is a perfect pit stop for ice cream lovers.

5. The Nutty Bean Café – Ice Cream Meets Coffee Perfection

📍33 Queen St., Lakefield

Not your typical ice cream shop, but hear me out. The Nutty Bean Café in Lakefield serves up locally made ice cream alongside some of the best coffee in the area. If you love affogatos (espresso poured over ice cream), this place is heaven. Try their Hazelnut Mocha Affogato—it’s a next-level treat for coffee and ice cream lovers alike.

Final Scoop

No matter where you go in Peterborough & the Kawarthas, you’re never too far from delicious, creamy, and locally made ice cream. Whether you're all about classic flavors or love trying something new and unique, these spots will satisfy your sweet tooth every time.

🍦 Did I miss your favorite ice cream shop? Drop a comment and let me know where YOU go for the best scoop in the area!